I was torn between this and the vest. I ended up going with the vest. Both were so comfy and had a lovely detail with the baker on the inside with a comfy cotton liner. They both zip up with buttons on the outside with I loved because I felt it added an extra little detail. I'm 5'10 and generally have problems finding jackets to fit my long arms but a size M fit perfectly so it's super versatile on size. Could even size up and add a layer on the inside. I really needed the vest, if I could, I would have bought both!